Review: That Guy…Who Was in That Thing (2012)

Posted by Jessica Finch June 19, 2013 0 Comment 7151 views

That Guy…Who Was in That Thing features interviews with 16 of Hollywood’s most recognizable character actors. The title of the film is very apt as each actor is, at once, both recognizable, but un-nameable, therefore becoming “that guy who was in that thing.”  It’s interesting to hear about the Hollywood ‘game’ of auditions and politics from the perspective of background players, but overall there was too much emphasis on talking heads, and not enough other visuals (short of movie stills) to keep the film going.

That Guy…Who Was in That Thing also had very little structure in terms of the interview topics. It seemed to be more free flowing conversation with actors like Robert Joy, Paul Guilfoyle (of CSI fame) and others, that was cut up after the fact and spliced together. As a result the whole film feels longer than it should. A better approach would have been to focus on fewer subjects and get a more in depth sense of their experience as opposed to stuffing the (similar) stories of 16 actors into one doc. It also would have been great to see some of the experiences being described. For instance, all the actors in the doc discuss their dislike of the audition process, but an actual audition is never shown! It would have been great to see an audition from their perspective (perhaps a hidden camera on the lapel?) This may have been difficult to accomplish because of rights issues, but it would have benefited the film greatly.

I’m curious about why That Guy…Who Was in That Thing  focused solely on male players. Would the title not have worked if actresses had been included? More women, and more minorities should have been featured in this film to break up the monotony of the white male actor experience. By including only white males, the filmmakers seem to be suggesting that only these actors are recognizable, but I can think of many talented female players that warranted a mention.

Another area where That Guy…Who Was in That Thing falls flat is the cinematography. A lot of the interviews are too dark, too bright or don’t match previous shots for the same subject. The whole thing feels very amateur, and the film does not do justice to these hardworking folks, who barely get enough recognition as it is. I would recommend this film for anyone looking to learn a few amusing tidbits about male American character actors (but nothing more).

About Jessica Finch

Jessica Finch is an avid writer and film enthusiast who has been contributing documentary reviews for Pretty Clever Films since March 2013. She is a graduate of Ryerson University’s Radio & Television Arts program and has worked as a freelance producer and production designer on short films and music videos. Jessica currently works as a sales coordinator at Achilles Media, an events management company in Toronto.

View all post by Jessica Finch

Write Your Comment

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.